Reviewlist › Guides
What 3,000 Mac App Store reviews say about Mac productivity apps
The 500 most recent US Mac App Store reviews of six productivity apps for the Mac, Fantastical, Bear, Things 3, Spark Mail, Todoist and Day One, read on 18 November 2026: how many are 1 or 2 stars, which words come up in those reviews, and how recent versions were received. Load any of them in the form above to see today's reviews.
Popular: ChatGPT · Duolingo · Spotify · Instagram · TikTok · Uber · all apps
| Date | Stars | Review | Version |
|---|
Free or Pro
Free: one app, one country, up to 500 reviews, CSV and JSON. Pro: all 183 countries in one run, both review lists (up to 1,000 per country), compare up to 5 apps, star, version and date filters, Excel export and a shareable HTML report (sample). $9 a month or $49 a year, 14-day refund.
The numbers
| App | Average of the last 500 | 1–2★ share | Those 500 reviews cover |
|---|---|---|---|
| Day One | 4.46 | 10% | Jul 2024 – Nov 2026 |
| Todoist | 4.30 | 14% | Nov 2020 – Oct 2026 |
| Spark Mail | 4.21 | 14% | Dec 2025 – Nov 2026 |
| Things 3 | 4.16 | 17% | May 2019 – Nov 2026 |
| Bear | 3.80 | 23% | Jan 2017 – Nov 2026 |
| Fantastical | 3.71 | 29% | Oct 2021 – Nov 2026 |
A calm category: no app here has more than 29% 1–2★ reviews. Fantastical has the most, 143 of its latest 500; Day One the fewest, 50 (10%). Mac apps collect reviews slowly: Bear's latest 500 go back to 2017 and Things 3's to 2019; only Spark Mail got 500 within a year. Written reviews lean negative everywhere, since the App Store rating also counts star-only ratings, so read this as a comparison.
What the 1–2★ reviews are about
For each app, the number of its 1–2★ reviews that mention a word (common words and the app's own name removed):
- Fantastical (143 bad reviews): calendar 61, subscription 48, features 33, pay 25, support 21, paid 20, free 20, mac 20, update 17, paying 16.
- Bear (116): notes 47, sync 28, subscription 27, support 24, work 23, version 19, markdown 18, evernote 17, devices 16, icloud 15.
- Things 3 (84): sync 16, features 16, task 15, support 13, version 13, work 12, list 12, iphone 11.
- Spark Mail (70): email 21, version 20, classic 19, desktop 16, update 16, features 9, old 9, interface 8, unusable 8.
- Todoist (68): tasks 13, mac 12, work 10, version 10, update 9, subscription 8, support 8, crashes 7.
- Day One (50): journal 17, subscription 9, entries 8, support 8, paid 7, money 7, free 6, pay 6.
"Subscription" is in four of the six lists (not Things 3's or Spark Mail's) and is second in Fantastical's (48), with pay, paid, free and paying. Bear's and Things 3's lists have "sync"; Spark Mail's has classic, desktop and old.
Ratings by version
- Spark Mail: 3.92 to 4.66 on six versions from 3.27.4 to 3.30.12; 3.30.12, the latest, is the lowest.
- Todoist: 4.48 to 4.67 on five versions from 7.4 to 8.0.1.
- Things 3: 4.75 on 3.9. Bear: 3.74 on 1.5.5. Day One: 4.92 on 2024.25.
- Fantastical: no single version has 25 of the 500 reviews.
Versions with at least 25 of the 500 reviews.
Repeat it for any app
Type an app in the form above and press Get reviews (Mac apps work the same way as iPhone apps): the summary shows the star split, a table by version and the most frequent words in 1–2★ reviews (click one to filter). Compare five of them side by side: load Fantastical, Bear, Things 3, Spark Mail and Todoist (Pro, or the free 3-day trial; Pro also makes a ready-to-send HTML report). To track them every week without opening the site, schedule the App Store Reviews Scraper on Apify with their IDs (975937182, 1091189122, 904280696, 6445813049, 585829637, 1055511498) and "Only reviews since: 7 days"; it returns the same data plus an HTML report by version, at $0.08 per 1,000 reviews. All reports: App Store review reports; iPhone to-do apps are in the to-do and calendar report, other Mac apps in the utility and creative reports.
Method: Apple's public customer reviews feed, US store, most recent order, 10 pages × 50 reviews per app, duplicates removed. Word counts: number of 1–2★ reviews containing the word at least once, in the title or text.
Need more than one country or app?
Reviewlist Pro loads all 183 countries in one run, both review lists (up to 1,000 per country), up to 5 apps side by side, and exports to Excel or a ready-to-send HTML report. $9 a month or $49 a year, cancel any time, 3-day free trial in the browser.
More guides
- Download App Store reviews
- App Store reviews by country
- App Store reviews by star rating
- App Store reviews by app version
- App Store reviews in Excel and Google Sheets
- Compare reviews of competing apps
- Analyze App Store reviews: bugs, requests, prices
- App Store reviews RSS feed and API for developers
- Find ASO keywords and competitor gaps in reviews
- App Store reviews as JSON, and analysis with a chatbot
- A free alternative to AppFollow for review exports
- A free alternative to Appbot for review exports
- Check App Store keyword rankings for free
- App Store keyword rankings by country
- Monitor new App Store reviews (Slack, email, Sheets)
- Export reviews from App Store Connect to CSV
- Mac App Store reviews to CSV or Excel
- One update can cost a star: 31 real examples
- Which country writes the angriest App Store reviews?
- App Store review reports by category
- Find app ideas in 1-star reviews
- How to reply to App Store reviews
- Deutsch: App-Store-Bewertungen exportieren
- Español: exportar reseñas de la App Store
- Français : exporter les avis de l'App Store
More reports
- Report: 3,000 reviews of competitive mobile games
- Report: 3,000 reviews of premium mobile games
- Report: 2,000 reviews of Mac utilities
- Report: 2,500 reviews of Mac creative apps
- Report: 3,000 reviews of invitation and wishlist apps
- Report: 2,500 reviews of selfie and photo editor apps
- Report: 3,000 reviews of music tool apps
- Report: 3,000 reviews of HR and payroll apps
- All 163 App Store review reports